Livingston Today

In 2018, Michigan voters approved Proposal 2, which aimed to establish an independent commission to put an end to partisan manipulation of political maps. The group behind the initiative, Voters Not Politicians, assured the public that this commission would ensure fair representation for all and create an impartial redistricting process that would eliminate gerrymandering. Unfortunately, recent revelations have shattered these promises, revealing a narrative of partisan influence, self-interest, and manipulation.

The Michigan Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission, initially seen as a symbol of fairness, has now been tainted by troubling news. It has come to light that two of its members, who were entrusted with redrawing political districts, had been living outside of Michigan. These commissioners continued to hold their titles and collect their salaries while residing in other states for over a year, effectively removing themselves from the consequences of their district-drawing decisions. It was only recently that they resigned after their situations were made public.

Furthermore, allegations have emerged regarding Commissioner Anthony Eid, raising concerns about the commission's impartiality. It is claimed that Eid, who ran as an independent, collaborated with specific Democratic candidates and personal allies to draw favorable districts before the 2022 election. These actions seriously undermine the credibility of the commission and cast doubts on Eid's ability to act independently.

This is not what the people of Michigan voted for. They wanted an independent commission that would be free from political influence and work transparently to ensure fair representation. Instead, we are witnessing a process tainted by partisanship and individuals more focused on personal agendas than the democratic rights of Michigan voters.

Transparency has been lacking throughout the entire process. The language in Proposal 2 left significant gaps, creating ambiguity and room for exploitation. It is crucial that a more rigorous vetting process be implemented for commissioners, delving deeper to uncover any potential partisan connections and ensuring that future members truly embody independence.

As we grapple with these troubling revelations, it is imperative that we demand accountability and transparency from the Michigan Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission. A comprehensive review of its practices is needed, along with investigations into all allegations of impropriety. Closing loopholes to ensure that commissioners are Michigan residents is just one of many reforms that must be implemented immediately as the commission embarks on redoing its work in the face of a lawsuit over voting rights violations.

Looking ahead to the redistricting cycle after the 2030 census, it is essential that we find ways to improve the process of selecting commissioners to guarantee true independence and reinforce our commitment to representing the residents of Michigan.

Representative Ann Bollin, who represents Michigan's 49th House District, has voiced her concerns about the shortcomings of the redistricting commission. She emphasizes the need for clarity, openness, and accountability to prevent a repeat of the current chaos. Bollin brings her experience as the former Brighton Township Clerk, having served for 16 years before entering the Legislature.

The people of Michigan voted for a fair, transparent, and genuinely independent redistricting process, and it is their right to receive one. Only through clarity, openness, and accountability can we ensure that their democratic rights are upheld and that the commission fulfills its intended purpose.

To find out more, go to this link: https://gophouse.org/posts/column-redistricting-commission-hasnt-delivered-fair-transparent-process-people-were-promised